President Donald Trump has built a public identity on being a dealmaker. Although his Wall Street days are long behind him, his time at the negotiating table is ever-present. Throughout his second term, specifically, Trump has vastly expanded the size and scope of bilateral negotiations with foreign countries. Yet, stalled talks with Russia, China, and Iran amid tense times have exposed the limits of his business-oriented approach to diplomacy. While Trump has entered discussions with “America First” rhetoric, his highly transactional diplomacy has unnerved allies and given America the short end of the stick.
In his first term, Trump’s diplomacy was more improvisational than anything. The outcomes of negotiations were frequently announced publicly, at whim, rather than through diplomatic channels. In his second term, his impromptu attitude remained. However, a new aspect emerged: maximalism—demanding everything at once. While Trump’s personalistic and transactional diplomacy manifested as isolated incidents in 2016, it has become a structural facet of American statecraft in 2026. This attitude, of maximal pressure, transactional leverage, and a heavy emphasis on Trump himself, has implicated international relations both at home and abroad.
When Trump enters the negotiating room, his strategy is three-fold. First, he reframes negotiations by demanding an extreme option that forces the other party to reassess their baseline. Next, he uses public leverage to coerce the other party into capitulating to his demands. Lastly, he whittles his original request down to a more moderate agreement compared to his opening, while still expanding America’s interests and framing it as a win-win for both nations.
This strategy adheres to the maxim of aiming for the moon and landing amongst the stars and has underpinned American foreign policy under Trump.
This approach is clearest in US-China diplomacy. When Trump took office in 2025, he quickly announced broad tariffs on all Chinese imports, in a move to protect American businesses. This maximalist demand shocked China. In the months since, American and Chinese diplomats have spent countless hours paring down Trump’s initial demands. In September, the two announced a modification to Trump’s tariffs, agreeing to cut taxes on agricultural and household products. Then, United States Trade Representative Jamieson Greer praised the deal as “unlocking improved market access,” completing Trump’s cycle.
This is Trump’s diplomatic playbook: demand, coerce, retreat. And while tariff negotiations are still underway, this strategy has strained relations with America’s allies who were caught in the crossfire. When the broad, baseline tariffs were announced in April 2025, allies such as Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and the European Union all felt similar tariff hikes.
In response, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni warned that Trump’s gambit would “inevitably weaken the West.” While some countries, like Japan and South Korea, stuck by America and offered investment deals to demonstrate their commitment to Washington, others sought alternative approaches. Canada, the European Union, and Mexico all responded to the tariffs with reciprocal counter-tariffs to showcase their resolve against US antagonism. Whether or not these developments will strengthen or weaken the US in the long term is unclear. However, when allies start to coerce each other financially, it highlights the volatile dynamics of Trump’s diplomacy.
The same pattern appears beyond trade. In Ukraine's case, Trump has applied more pressure on Kyiv than on Moscow. He urged Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy to halt all attacks on Russian oil refineries, pressured Ukraine toward accepting territorial concessions, and blamed Zelenskyy for the conflict. This maximalist bid has been met with backlash, as members of NATO fear Trump is sidelining European security in favor of appeasing Russia. However, Trump claimed these actions, alongside waivers on Russian oil sanctions, were meant to bring Russia back to the bargaining table. Regardless of Trump’s intentions, some European officials have interpreted his actions as another attempt to get closer to Russia, while sacrificing Europe in the process.
In Iran, Trump has demonstrated his maximalist posture with a combination of multi-domain blockades, aggressive sanctions, and forward-deployed aircraft to force Iran to the negotiating table. However, the efficacy of these tactics remains to be seen, as Iran controls access to the Strait of Hormuz, giving Iran ultimate leverage in negotiations.
Supporters of Trump’s foreign policy argue that extreme demands, pervasive public pressure, and Trump’s personality are what bring foreign countries to the negotiating table. Greer, for one, argues that tariffs have contributed more than 30,000 manufacturing jobs in 2026. In contrast, the Federal Reserve found that 90% of the tariffs’ costs would fall onto consumers and U.S. businesses. While the effects of US-China tariff talks are unclear, the renewed round of diplomacy has created an opening for the United States to seek further concessions from foreign powers.
In Ukraine, while negotiations continue to stall, Trump’s diplomacy has directly increased unilateral discussions with Moscow concerning the war. Compared to the Biden administration, this breakthrough in dialogue has created a stable middle ground for future discussions, helping maintain crisis stability, even amid active conflict.
In Iran, while many argue Trump lacks true leverage over the situation, others point out that his maximalist pressure on Iran’s financial status has forced the country into negotiations. Emily Harding, vice president of the Defense and Security Department at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, notes that heavy economic pressure has forced Iran back into negotiations with the United States, a vital concession to avoid total economic collapse.
The question, therefore, is not whether Trump is willing to negotiate, but whether his maximalist diplomacy can make agreements last. To some, Trump blusters more than he brokers. To others, his hardliner stance is exactly what is needed to confront adversaries across the globe. As allies closely watch American diplomacy unfold under Trump, the outcome will shape how much weight they place on U.S. commitments. As the world watches, both the future of U.S. statecraft and Trump’s reputation are on the line.